The Hook: How to Make Alkenes from Alkyl Halides
Ever wondered how plastic polymers like polyethylene are made? It all starts with ethylene (H₂C=CH₂), which comes from elimination reactions! When you heat ethyl alcohol with concentrated H₂SO₄, water is eliminated to form ethylene - the building block of plastics worth billions of dollars.
Here’s the JEE question: Why does treating 2-bromobutane with alcoholic KOH give mainly 2-butene, not 1-butene? And why does the same reaction give different products with aqueous vs alcoholic KOH?
The Core Concept
What is Elimination?
Elimination is the removal of two atoms/groups from adjacent carbons to form a double bond.
General Reaction:
$$\boxed{\text{R-CH}_2\text{-CHX-R'} + \text{Base} \rightarrow \text{R-CH=CH-R'} + \text{HX}}$$Also called: β-elimination or 1,2-elimination
Key terms:
- α-carbon: Carbon bearing leaving group (X)
- β-carbon: Adjacent carbon (has H to be removed)
- β-hydrogen: Hydrogen on β-carbon
E2 Mechanism: Bimolecular Elimination
What is E2?
E2 = Elimination Bimolecular
“Bimolecular” means rate depends on BOTH alkyl halide and base.
The Mechanism (One Step)
Concerted process - all bonds break and form simultaneously
Three things happen at once:
- Base removes β-hydrogen
- C-H bond breaks
- C-X bond breaks
- π bond forms
Example: 2-bromobutane + KOH (alcoholic)
$$\text{CH}_3\text{CH}_2\text{CHBr-CH}_3 + \text{OH}^- \xrightarrow{\text{C}_2\text{H}_5\text{OH}} \text{CH}_3\text{CH=CH-CH}_3 + \text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Br}^-$$Rate Equation
$$\boxed{\text{Rate} = k[\text{R-X}][\text{Base}]}$$Why bimolecular?
- Both R-X and base involved in rate-determining step
- Increasing either concentration increases rate
Stereochemistry: Anti-Periplanar Geometry
Most Important for JEE Advanced!
E2 requires specific geometry:
- H and X must be anti-periplanar (180° dihedral angle)
- Both must be in same plane
- On opposite sides of C-C bond
Why this geometry?
- Allows orbital overlap for π bond formation
- Lower activation energy
- Most stable transition state
Newman Projection:
Q: Why doesn’t the following compound undergo E2 elimination easily?
Br
|
[Rigid cyclic structure where H and Br are cis]
Answer:
In a rigid ring system, if H and Br are cis (same side), they CANNOT achieve anti-periplanar geometry!
For E2, need:
- H and Br on opposite sides (trans)
- 180° dihedral angle
JEE Tip: When given cyclic compounds, check if H and leaving group can be anti!
Factors Affecting E2 Rate
Factor 1: Structure of Alkyl Halide
Reactivity order:
$$\boxed{3° > 2° > 1°}$$Why?
- More substituted alkene is more stable (product stability)
- More alkyl groups on α-carbon help C-X bond breaking
- Hyperconjugation stabilizes transition state
Factor 2: Base Strength
Strong bases favor E2
Good E2 bases:
- OH⁻ (hydroxide)
- OR⁻ (alkoxide) - e.g., C₂H₅O⁻
- NH₂⁻ (amide)
Effect of base size:
- Small strong base (OH⁻, OMe⁻): Can also do substitution
- Bulky strong base (t-BuO⁻): Prefers elimination over substitution
“Big Bases prefer Beta (β-elimination)”
For elimination:
- Bulky bases (tert-butoxide): E2 predominates
- High temperature: Favors elimination
For substitution:
- Small bases (methoxide): SN2 can compete
- Low temperature: Favors substitution
JEE Strategy:
- t-BuO⁻ + 2° or 3° halide → E2 (almost exclusive)
- OH⁻ + 1° halide → SN2 (competes)
Interactive Demo: Visualize E1 and E2 Elimination Mechanisms
Watch how β-hydrogen is removed and double bonds form in real-time.
Factor 3: Leaving Group
Better leaving group = faster E2
Same order as SN1/SN2:
$$\boxed{\text{I}^- > \text{Br}^- > \text{Cl}^- > \text{F}^-}$$Factor 4: Solvent
E2 works in both protic and aprotic solvents
Common E2 solvents:
- Alcoholic KOH (C₂H₅OH + KOH)
- Hot alcohol with base
- DMSO with strong base
E1 Mechanism: Unimolecular Elimination
What is E1?
E1 = Elimination Unimolecular
“Unimolecular” means rate depends ONLY on alkyl halide concentration.
The Mechanism (Two Steps)
Step 1: Ionization (SLOW - Rate Determining)
$$\boxed{\text{R-X} \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} \text{R}^+ + \text{X}^-}$$Forms carbocation intermediate (same as SN1!)
Step 2: Deprotonation (FAST)
$$\boxed{\text{R}^+ \xrightarrow{\text{-H}^+, \text{ fast}} \text{Alkene}}$$Base removes β-hydrogen, forming π bond.
Example: tert-butyl bromide + H₂O (heat)
Step 1:
$$(CH_3)_3C-Br \xrightarrow{\text{slow}} (CH_3)_3C^+ + Br^-$$Step 2: Base removes β-hydrogen from adjacent carbon, electrons form π bond with carbocation.
Rate Equation
$$\boxed{\text{Rate} = k[\text{R-X}]}$$Why unimolecular?
- Rate depends ONLY on [R-X]
- Base NOT involved in slow step
- Same as SN1!
Same carbocation as SN1! → E1 and SN1 compete
Factors Affecting E1 Rate
Factor 1: Structure
Reactivity order:
$$\boxed{3° > 2° > 1°}$$Why?
- More stable carbocation → faster ionization
- Same reason as SN1!
Factor 2: Solvent
Polar protic solvents favor E1
Best E1 solvents:
- Water (H₂O)
- Alcohols (heat)
- Dilute acids
Why?
- Stabilize carbocation intermediate
- Same as SN1
Factor 3: Temperature
High temperature favors E1
Why?
- Elimination is entropically favored (creates more molecules)
- Heat provides energy for C-X bond breaking
Both mechanisms:
- Same first step (carbocation formation)
- Same substrate preference (3° > 2°)
- Same solvent preference (polar protic)
How to favor E1 over SN1:
- Higher temperature (E1 favored)
- Stronger base (removes H⁺ faster)
- Less nucleophilic solvent
Typical conditions:
- SN1: Low temp, good nucleophile (H₂O, ROH)
- E1: High temp, poor nucleophile or weak base
JEE Tip: If conditions favor carbocation formation BUT high temperature → expect E1!
Carbocation Rearrangements in E1
Just like SN1, E1 can have rearrangements!
Example:
CH₃ CH₃
| |
CH₃—C—CH₂Br → CH₃—C—CH₂⁺ → (rearrange) → CH₃—C⁺—CH₃
| | |
CH₃ CH₃ CH₃
→ CH₂=C(CH₃)₂
Saytzeff’s Rule: Predicting Major Product
The Rule
Saytzeff’s Rule (Zaitsev’s Rule):
In elimination, the more substituted alkene is the major product.
Also stated as:
Hydrogen is preferentially removed from the β-carbon with fewer hydrogens.
Why More Substituted is More Stable
Alkene stability order:
$$\boxed{\text{Tetrasubstituted} > \text{Trisubstituted} > \text{Disubstituted} > \text{Monosubstituted}}$$Reasons:
- Hyperconjugation: More alkyl groups = more hyperconjugation
- Inductive effect: Alkyl groups donate electrons, stabilize π bond
Q: What are the products when 2-bromobutane undergoes elimination?
Structure: CH₃-CHBr-CH₂-CH₃
Possible products:
Product 1: 2-butene (more substituted)
$$\text{CH}_3\text{-CH=CH-CH}_3$$- Two alkyl groups on C=C
- Disubstituted alkene
- Major product (Saytzeff)
Product 2: 1-butene (less substituted)
$$\text{CH}_2\text{=CH-CH}_2\text{-CH}_3$$- One alkyl group on C=C
- Monosubstituted alkene
- Minor product
Ratio: ~80% 2-butene : 20% 1-butene
JEE Rule: “Saytzeff says: More Substituted!”
Counting β-Hydrogens
Method to predict major product:
- Identify α-carbon (has X)
- Identify all β-carbons (adjacent to α)
- Count hydrogens on each β-carbon
- Removal from β-carbon with fewer H gives more substituted alkene
Example:
β₂ α β₁
| | |
CH₃-CH-CHBr-CH₃
|
CH₃
β₁: 3 hydrogens (CH₃ group)
β₂: 1 hydrogen (CH group)
Removal from β₂ (fewer H) → more substituted alkene → major product
“S for Saytzeff, S for Substituted”
Saytzeff product:
- More Substituted
- More Stable
- Standard conditions (alcoholic KOH)
To remember: “Zaitsev Zays: Zore Zubstituents!” (phonetically)
Hofmann Elimination: Exception to Saytzeff
When Does Hofmann Occur?
Hofmann elimination gives less substituted alkene as major product.
Conditions for Hofmann:
- Bulky base (difficult to reach more substituted position)
- Quaternary ammonium salts (R₄N⁺X⁻)
- Leaving group with extra positive charge
Hofmann’s Rule
With bulky bases or quaternary ammonium salts, less substituted alkene is major product.
Why?
- Bulky base cannot easily approach more hindered β-carbon
- Removes H from less hindered (more accessible) position
- Steric factors override thermodynamic stability
Q: What is the major product from Hofmann elimination of:
$$\text{(CH}_3)_2\text{CH-CH}_2\text{-N}^+(\text{CH}_3)_3 \text{ OH}^- \xrightarrow{\text{heat}} ?$$Analysis:
Possible products:
Product 1: (CH₃)₂C=CH₂ (more substituted - Saytzeff) Product 2: CH₃-CH=CH-CH₃ (less substituted)
With quaternary ammonium + heat (Hofmann conditions):
Major product: CH₂=CH-CH(CH₃)₂ (less substituted)
Why?
- Large N(CH₃)₃ group creates steric hindrance
- Base preferentially removes H from less hindered position
- Hofmann product predominates
JEE Tip: Hofmann elimination is exception to Saytzeff - look for bulky groups!
E1 vs E2: The Big Comparison
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | E2 | E1 |
|---|---|---|
| Full Name | Elimination Bimolecular | Elimination Unimolecular |
| Steps | 1 step (concerted) | 2 steps (via carbocation) |
| Rate Equation | Rate = k[R-X][Base] | Rate = k[R-X] |
| Intermediate | Transition state only | Carbocation intermediate |
| Substrate | 3° ≥ 2° > 1° | 3° > 2° » 1° |
| Base | Strong base required | Weak base OK |
| Stereochemistry | Anti-periplanar required | No restriction |
| Rearrangement | No rearrangement | Can rearrange |
| Major product | Saytzeff (usually) | Saytzeff |
| Competes with | SN2 | SN1 |
| Temperature | Any temperature | High temperature favors |
The “BEAST” Rule for E2:
- Bimolecular (rate depends on [R-X][Base])
- Elimination in one step
- Anti-periplanar geometry
- Strong base needed
- Transition state (no intermediate)
The “CHAIR” Rule for E1:
- Carbocation intermediate
- High temperature favors
- All-around geometry (no restriction)
- Ionization first (slow step)
- Rearrangement possible
Master these and you’ll never confuse them!
Substitution vs Elimination: The Competition
When Do They Compete?
SN2 vs E2 - compete under similar conditions SN1 vs E1 - share same first step (carbocation)
Factors Determining Substitution vs Elimination
Factor 1: Structure of Substrate
Primary (1°):
- SN2 strongly favored
- E2 very slow (less stable alkene product)
- Ratio: ~90% SN2, 10% E2
Secondary (2°):
- Both compete
- Small base → SN2
- Bulky base → E2
- High temp → E2
Tertiary (3°):
- SN2 doesn’t occur (too hindered)
- E2 strongly favored
- Can also do E1/SN1 in polar protic solvents
For Primary (1°) Substrate:
- Strong small base → SN2 (major)
- Strong bulky base → E2 (major)
For Secondary (2°) Substrate:
- Strong base, low temp → SN2
- Strong base, high temp → E2
- Bulky base → E2
For Tertiary (3°) Substrate:
- Strong base → E2 (major)
- Weak nucleophile, polar protic → SN1/E1 mixture
- High temp → E1 over SN1
Memory: “1° loves SN2, 3° loves E2, 2° is confused!”
Factor 2: Base/Nucleophile
Strong nucleophile + small base:
- Favors substitution (SN2)
- Examples: I⁻, CN⁻, RS⁻
Strong base + bulky:
- Favors elimination (E2)
- Examples: t-BuO⁻, LDA
Weak nucleophile:
- With 3°: SN1/E1 mixture
- With 1°: Very slow reactions
Factor 3: Solvent
Polar aprotic (acetone, DMSO):
- Favors SN2
- Can also support E2
Polar protic (H₂O, ROH):
- Favors SN1/E1 for 3° substrates
- Heat: E1 predominates
Factor 4: Temperature
Low temperature:
- Kinetic control
- Favors substitution
High temperature:
- Thermodynamic control
- Favors elimination (ΔS positive)
Q: Predict major product and mechanism for each:
(a) CH₃CH₂Br + OH⁻ in ethanol (room temp) (b) (CH₃)₂CHBr + t-BuO⁻ in t-BuOH (c) (CH₃)₃CBr + H₂O (heat) (d) CH₃CH₂CH₂Br + CN⁻ in acetone
Solutions:
(a) SN2 major, some E2
- 1° substrate
- Strong base, moderate temp
- Products: CH₃CH₂OH (major) + CH₂=CH₂ (minor)
(b) E2 exclusively
- 2° substrate
- Bulky strong base (t-BuO⁻)
- Product: CH₃CH=CH₂
(c) E1 major, some SN1
- 3° substrate
- Weak nucleophile, heat
- Products: (CH₃)₂C=CH₂ (major E1) + (CH₃)₃COH (minor SN1)
(d) SN2 exclusively
- 1° substrate
- Strong nucleophile (CN⁻), poor base
- Polar aprotic solvent
- Product: CH₃CH₂CH₂CN
JEE Strategy: Systematically check: substrate (1°/2°/3°), base/Nu strength, solvent, temperature!
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Wrong: “All β-hydrogens removed equally”
Correct: Preferentially removes H from β-carbon with fewer H atoms
Example: 2-bromopentane gives mainly 2-pentene (trisubstituted), not 1-pentene (disubstituted)
JEE Tip: Always identify more substituted alkene - that’s Saytzeff product!
Wrong: “Strong base means E1”
Correct:
- Strong base → E2 (bimolecular)
- Weak base + heat → E1 (via carbocation)
Memory: “Strong (2 syllables) goes with E2”
Wrong: Predicting E1 product without considering rearrangement
Correct: E1 has carbocation intermediate → CAN rearrange
Example:
CH₃-CH(CH₃)-CH₂Br → (via E1)
↓ (ionization)
CH₃-CH(CH₃)-CH₂⁺ → (rearrange)
↓ (1,2-H shift)
CH₃-C⁺(CH₃)-CH₃ → (elimination)
↓
CH₂=C(CH₃)₂ (rearranged product!)
JEE Strategy: For E1, always check carbocation stability and rearrangement possibility!
Wrong: “1° substrate with strong base gives only E2”
Correct: 1° substrate favors SN2, even with strong base
Competition depends on:
- Substrate (1°/2°/3°)
- Base size (small/bulky)
- Temperature
JEE Rule:
- 1° + any base → SN2 major (unless very bulky base + heat)
- 3° + strong base → E2 major
- 2° → depends on conditions!
Practice Problems
Level 1: Foundation (NCERT)
Q: Identify E1 or E2 mechanism:
(a) CH₃CH₂Br + KOH (alcoholic) → CH₂=CH₂ (b) (CH₃)₃CBr + H₂O (heat) → (CH₃)₂C=CH₂
Solutions:
(a) E2
- Strong base (KOH)
- Alcoholic solution
- One-step concerted mechanism
- Rate = k[R-X][OH⁻]
(b) E1
- Weak base (H₂O)
- 3° substrate forms stable carbocation
- Heat provides energy
- Two-step mechanism
- Rate = k[(CH₃)₃CBr]
Q: What is the major product from dehydrohalogenation of 2-bromobutane?
Solution:
Structure: CH₃-CHBr-CH₂-CH₃
Possible alkenes:
- CH₃-CH=CH-CH₃ (2-butene) - disubstituted
- CH₂=CH-CH₂-CH₃ (1-butene) - monosubstituted
Major product: 2-butene (CH₃-CH=CH-CH₃)
Reason: More substituted alkene (Saytzeff’s rule)
Additional: 2-butene exists as cis and trans isomers!
Level 2: JEE Main
Q: Which stereoisomer of 1,2-dibromocyclohexane undergoes E2 elimination faster?
(a) Both Br trans (axial-equatorial) (b) Both Br cis
Solution:
Answer: (a) Trans isomer
Reason:
- E2 requires anti-periplanar geometry
- H and Br must be 180° apart
- In chair conformation: both must be axial (diaxial)
- Trans diaxial is easily achieved
- Cis cannot achieve anti-periplanar
JEE Tip: For cyclic compounds in E2, check for diaxial arrangement!
Q: Major product when 2-bromopropane reacts with: (a) KOH in ethanol at 25°C (b) KOH in ethanol at 80°C
Solution:
Structure: CH₃-CHBr-CH₃ (2° substrate)
(a) At 25°C: SN2 major
- Product: CH₃-CHOH-CH₃ (2-propanol) - major
- Some CH₃-CH=CH₂ (propene) - minor
(b) At 80°C: E2 major
- Product: CH₃-CH=CH₂ (propene) - major
- Some CH₃-CHOH-CH₃ - minor
Reason: High temperature favors elimination (entropically favored)
Level 3: JEE Advanced
Q: What is the major product when 3,3-dimethyl-2-bromobutane undergoes E1 elimination?
Structure:
CH₃ Br
| |
CH₃—C—CH—CH₃
|
CH₃
Solution:
Step 1: Ionization
CH₃ Br CH₃ ⁺
| | | |
CH₃—C—CH—CH₃ → CH₃—C—CH—CH₃
| |
CH₃ CH₃
(2° carbocation - can rearrange)
Step 2: Rearrangement (1,2-CH₃ shift)
CH₃ ⁺ CH₃ CH₃
| | | |
CH₃—C—CH—CH₃ → CH₃—C⁺—C—CH₃
| |
CH₃ CH₃
2° carbocation 3° carbocation
Step 3: Elimination (remove H⁺)
H
|
CH₂—C⁺(CH₃)—C(CH₃)₂ → CH₂=C(CH₃)—C(CH₃)₂
2,3,3-trimethyl-1-butene
Answer: 2,3,3-trimethyl-1-butene (rearranged product)
JEE Tip: E1 can give unexpected products due to rearrangement!
Q: Predict major product:
(a) CH₃CH₂CH(Br)CH₃ + KOH/ethanol (b) CH₃CH₂CH(N⁺(CH₃)₃)CH₃ OH⁻ + heat
Solutions:
(a) Saytzeff product (E2 with normal base)
Products possible:
- CH₃CH=CHCH₃ (2-butene) - trisubstituted
- CH₃CH₂CH=CH₂ (1-butene) - disubstituted
Major: 2-butene (more substituted)
(b) Hofmann product (bulky leaving group)
Major: 1-butene (less substituted)
Reason:
- Quaternary ammonium has bulky N(CH₃)₃ group
- Steric hindrance prevents access to more substituted position
- Base removes H from less hindered terminal position
Ratio: ~70% 1-butene : 30% 2-butene (reversed from Saytzeff!)
Q: For each reaction, predict major mechanism (SN1/SN2/E1/E2) and major product:
(a) CH₃Br + CN⁻ in DMSO (b) (CH₃)₃CCl + CH₃OH (heat) (c) CH₃CH₂CH₂Br + t-BuO⁻ in t-BuOH (d) (CH₃)₂CHBr + I⁻ in acetone
Solutions:
(a) SN2 - CH₃CN
- Methyl substrate (no hindrance)
- Strong nucleophile
- Polar aprotic solvent
(b) E1 major, SN1 minor
- 3° substrate
- Weak nucleophile
- Protic solvent + heat
- Major: (CH₃)₂C=CH₂, Minor: (CH₃)₃COCH₃
(c) E2 - CH₃CH=CH₂
- 1° substrate BUT bulky base
- t-BuO⁻ is very hindered → can’t do SN2
- E2 predominates
(d) SN2 - (CH₃)₂CHI
- 2° substrate
- I⁻ is excellent nucleophile but poor base
- Polar aprotic solvent
- No heat → substitution favored
JEE Strategy: Consider ALL factors - substrate, base/Nu, solvent, temperature!
Quick Revision Box
| Topic | Key Points | JEE Rule |
|---|---|---|
| E2 | One step, anti-periplanar | Strong base, concerted |
| E1 | Two steps, via carbocation | Weak base + heat |
| Rate (E2) | k[R-X][Base] | Bimolecular |
| Rate (E1) | k[R-X] | Unimolecular |
| Substrate (E2) | 3° ≥ 2° > 1° | Strong base needed |
| Substrate (E1) | 3° > 2° » 1° | Stable carbocation |
| Saytzeff | More substituted alkene | Standard elimination |
| Hofmann | Less substituted alkene | Bulky base or R₄N⁺ |
| Rearrangement | E2: No, E1: Yes | Same as SN patterns |
| vs SN2 | 1° → SN2, 3° → E2 | Bulky base → E2 |
| vs SN1 | Both via carbocation | Heat → E1 |
Connection to Other Topics
Prerequisites:
- Alkyl Halides - Structure and reactivity
- SN1 and SN2 Reactions - Competition with elimination
- Carbocations - Stability and rearrangements
Produces:
Related Mechanisms:
- Dehydration of Alcohols - Also E1 mechanism
- Hofmann Degradation - Makes amines via elimination
Applications:
- Polymer Chemistry - Alkenes for polymerization
- Industrial Alkenes - Large-scale production
Teacher’s Summary
1. Two Elimination Mechanisms:
- E2: One step, needs strong base, anti-periplanar geometry
- E1: Two steps, carbocation intermediate, heat favors
2. Product Prediction (Saytzeff vs Hofmann):
- Saytzeff (normal): More substituted alkene (standard conditions)
- Hofmann (exception): Less substituted (bulky base or R₄N⁺)
3. Stereochemistry:
- E2: Requires anti-periplanar (H and X at 180°)
- E1: No restriction (carbocation is planar)
4. Rearrangements:
- E2: No rearrangement (concerted)
- E1: Can rearrange (carbocation intermediate)
5. Competition with Substitution (MOST IMPORTANT):
Primary (1°) substrates:
- Usually SN2 > E2 (unless bulky base)
Tertiary (3°) substrates:
- Usually E2 > E1/SN1 (strong base → E2, weak + heat → E1)
Secondary (2°) substrates:
- Depends on ALL factors (base, solvent, temperature)
- Strong + small → SN2
- Strong + bulky → E2
- Weak + protic + heat → E1
6. JEE Strategy Matrix:
1° Substrate 2° Substrate 3° Substrate
Small SN2 major SN2 or E2 SN1/E1
base
Bulky E2 (some) E2 major E2 only
base
“Master the competition between substitution and elimination - it’s the heart of alkyl halide chemistry!”