The Hook: From Formaldehyde Preservatives to Acetone Nail Polish
Ever wondered what preserves biological specimens in those lab jars? Formaldehyde (HCHO) - the simplest aldehyde! Or that strong smell from nail polish remover? That’s acetone (CH₃-CO-CH₃) - the simplest ketone!
But here’s the mind-blowing part: Both have the same functional group (C=O), but aldehydes get oxidized easily while ketones resist! Aldehydes reduce Tollens’ reagent to give a shiny silver mirror, but ketones just sit there doing nothing!
In 3 Idiots (2009), when Rancho tricks Chatur with the modified speech, he changes meanings completely - just like how aldehydes and ketones, despite having the same C=O group, behave completely differently!
The JEE Question: Why do aldehydes undergo both oxidation AND reduction, while ketones only get reduced? What makes nucleophilic addition to C=O so special? Master this, and you’ll crack 8-10 marks easily in JEE!
The Core Concept: The Carbonyl Group (C=O)
General Structure
Aldehydes:
$$\boxed{\text{R-CHO or R-C(=O)-H}}$$Ketones:
$$\boxed{\text{R-CO-R' or R-C(=O)-R'}}$$In simple terms:
- Aldehyde: Carbonyl group (C=O) at terminal position (end of chain), with at least one H on carbonyl carbon
- Ketone: Carbonyl group (C=O) within the chain, with two carbon groups (no H on carbonyl carbon)
Key Difference:
| Feature | Aldehyde (R-CHO) | Ketone (R-CO-R') |
|---|---|---|
| Carbonyl position | Terminal (end) | Internal (middle) |
| H on C=O carbon | Yes (at least 1 H) | No (no H) |
| Oxidation | Easy (to RCOOH) | Very difficult (C-C bond breaks) |
| Reactivity | More reactive | Less reactive |
Memory Trick: “Aldehyde is At the end, Ketone is Kaught in the middle!”
Interactive Demo: Visualize Nucleophilic Addition
Watch nucleophilic addition reactions to the carbonyl group step-by-step.
Nomenclature
IUPAC System:
| Common Name | IUPAC Name | Structure |
|---|---|---|
| Formaldehyde | Methanal | HCHO |
| Acetaldehyde | Ethanal | CH₃CHO |
| Propionaldehyde | Propanal | CH₃CH₂CHO |
| Acetone | Propanone | CH₃COCH₃ |
| Methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) | Butanone | CH₃COCH₂CH₃ |
Suffix:
- Aldehydes: -al
- Ketones: -one
Numbering:
- Aldehydes: C=O is always position 1 (no need to mention)
- Ketones: Number to give C=O lowest number
Why is C=O Special? The Reactivity Story
Polarity of Carbonyl Group
δ+ δ-
C=O
Reason: Oxygen is more electronegative than carbon
- Pulls electrons toward itself
- Makes C electron-deficient (δ+) → electrophilic center
- Makes O electron-rich (δ-) → nucleophilic center (but C is more important!)
Result: Nucleophilic addition is the characteristic reaction!
Nucleophilic Addition Mechanism (General)
δ+ δ- OH
| | |
Nu⁻ + R-C=O → R-C-Nu
| |
H (aldehyde) H
or R' (ketone) or R'
Steps:
Step 1: Nucleophilic attack on electrophilic carbon
δ-
Nu⁻ → C=O → C-O⁻
|
Nu
Step 2: Protonation of alkoxide
C-O⁻ + H⁺ → C-OH
| |
Nu Nu
Why aldehydes are MORE reactive than ketones:
Steric hindrance:
- Aldehydes: Only 1 R group + 1 H → less crowded → nucleophile attacks easily
- Ketones: 2 R groups → more crowded → nucleophile approach hindered
Electronic effect (+I effect):
- Aldehydes: 1 R group → less electron donation to C=O → C remains electrophilic
- Ketones: 2 R groups → more +I effect → C becomes less electrophilic
Memory Trick: “Aldehydes are Available (less hindered), Ketones are Krowded (more hindered)!”
Preparation of Aldehydes & Ketones
Method 1: Oxidation of Alcohols (Most Important!)
Pattern:
| Alcohol | Oxidizing Agent | Product |
|---|---|---|
| 1° Alcohol | PCC (mild) | Aldehyde (stops here) |
| 1° Alcohol | K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ (strong) | Carboxylic acid (goes further!) |
| 2° Alcohol | K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ or PCC | Ketone (stops here) |
| 3° Alcohol | Any oxidizing agent | No reaction |
Examples:
(a) 1° Alcohol → Aldehyde (using PCC):
PCC/CH₂Cl₂ O
(anhydrous) ‖
CH₃CH₂-CH₂-OH ──────────→ CH₃CH₂-C-H
(Propanal)
PCC = Pyridinium Chlorochromate: Mild oxidizing agent, stops at aldehyde stage!
(b) 2° Alcohol → Ketone:
K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ O
‖
CH₃-CH(OH)-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃-C-CH₃
(Propan-2-ol) (Propanone/Acetone)
Memory Trick:
- “PCC is Perfect for Preserving aldehydes (stops oxidation)!”
- “2° alcohol → 2nd oxygen product (ketone)”
Method 2: Ozonolysis of Alkenes
Reaction:
(1) O₃
R-CH=CH-R' ────────────→ R-CHO + R'-CHO
(2) Zn/H₂O
(reductive workup)
Example:
(1) O₃
CH₃-CH=CH₂ ────────────→ CH₃-CHO + HCHO
(2) Zn/H₂O (Acetaldehyde) (Formaldehyde)
Mechanism (Simplified):
Step 1: Ozone addition to C=C (forms ozonide)
R-CH=CH-R' + O₃ → R-CH-O-O-CH-R'
| |
O-----O
(Ozonide, unstable)
Step 2: Reductive cleavage
Ozonide + Zn/H₂O → R-CHO + R'-CHO
Product Prediction:
- Break C=C bond
- Add C=O to each carbon that was part of C=C
JEE Pattern: Given ozonolysis products, deduce the original alkene structure!
Method 3: Hydration of Alkynes (for Ketones)
Reaction:
H₂O, H₂SO₄
R-C≡C-H ────────────→ R-CO-CH₃
HgSO₄ (Methyl ketone)
Example:
H₂O, H₂SO₄
CH₃-C≡C-H ────────────→ CH₃-CO-CH₃
HgSO₄ (Acetone)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Markovnikov addition (forms enol)
H₂O, H⁺ OH
CH₃-C≡CH ──────→ CH₃-C=CH₂ (Enol, unstable!)
HgSO₄
Step 2: Tautomerization (keto-enol)
OH O
| ‖
CH₃-C=CH₂ ⇌ CH₃-C-CH₃ (Keto form, stable)
(Enol) (Ketone)
Note: Enols are generally unstable and tautomerize to more stable keto form!
Memory Trick: “Enols are Evanescent (short-lived), Keto is Konstant (stable)!”
Method 4: Friedel-Crafts Acylation (for Aromatic Ketones)
Reaction:
RCOCl
C₆H₆ + ────────→ C₆H₅-CO-R
AlCl₃ (Aromatic ketone)
Example:
CH₃COCl
C₆H₆ + ─────────→ C₆H₅-CO-CH₃ (Acetophenone)
AlCl₃
Cannot make aldehydes this way! (C₆H₅-CHO requires special reagent: Gattermann-Koch)
Method 5: From Nitriles and Acyl Chlorides (Advanced)
Rosenmund Reduction (Acyl chloride → Aldehyde):
H₂/Pd-BaSO₄ O
(poisoned catalyst) ‖
R-COCl ────────────────→ R-C-H
(Aldehyde)
Example:
H₂/Pd-BaSO₄
CH₃COCl ──────────→ CH₃CHO
(Acetaldehyde)
Why poisoned catalyst? Prevents over-reduction to alcohol!
Reactions of Aldehydes & Ketones: The Main Arsenal
Reaction 1: Nucleophilic Addition - Addition of HCN
Reaction:
HCN OH
| |
R-C=O → R-C-CN (Cyanohydrin)
| |
H (aldehyde) H
or R' (ketone) or R'
Example:
HCN OH
CH₃CHO → CH₃-CH-CN (2-Hydroxypropanenitrile)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Nucleophilic attack by CN⁻ (from HCN ⇌ H⁺ + CN⁻)
δ-
CN⁻ → C=O → C-O⁻
|
CN
Step 2: Protonation
C-O⁻ + H⁺ → C-OH
| |
CN CN
Importance: Cyanohydrins are useful intermediates!
- Hydrolysis: R-CH(OH)-CN → R-CH(OH)-COOH (α-hydroxy acid)
- Reduction: R-CH(OH)-CN → R-CH(OH)-CH₂-NH₂ (β-amino alcohol)
Reaction 2: Nucleophilic Addition - Addition of NaHSO₃
Reaction:
NaHSO₃ OH
| |
R-CHO → R-CH-SO₃Na (Bisulfite adduct, white crystalline solid!)
Example:
NaHSO₃ OH
CH₃CHO ────────→ CH₃-CH-SO₃Na
(White precipitate)
Uses:
- Purification of aldehydes/ketones (crystalline solid easy to isolate)
- Qualitative test for aldehydes and methyl ketones (white ppt)
Note: Only works well with aldehydes and methyl ketones (sterically less hindered)!
Reverse Reaction (regenerate carbonyl):
R-CH(OH)-SO₃Na + HCl or Na₂CO₃ → R-CHO + NaHSO₃
Reaction 3: Nucleophilic Addition - Addition of Grignard Reagent
Pattern:
| Carbonyl + Grignard | Product Alcohol Class |
|---|---|
| Formaldehyde (HCHO) + RMgX | 1° alcohol |
| Other aldehyde (R’CHO) + RMgX | 2° alcohol |
| Ketone (R’COR") + RMgX | 3° alcohol |
Example 1:
(1) CH₃MgBr
HCHO ──────────────→ CH₃CH₂OH
(2) H₃O⁺ (1° alcohol)
Example 2:
(1) CH₃MgBr
CH₃CHO ──────────────→ (CH₃)₂CHOH
(2) H₃O⁺ (2° alcohol)
Example 3:
(1) CH₃MgBr
CH₃COCH₃ ──────────────→ (CH₃)₃COH
(2) H₃O⁺ (3° alcohol)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Nucleophilic attack by R⁻ (from RMgX)
δ- O⁻MgX
R⁻ → C=O → R-C-R'
|
H (or R")
Step 2: Hydrolysis (acidic workup)
O⁻MgX OH
| H₃O⁺ |
R-C-R' ───────→ R-C-R'
| |
H (or R") H (or R")
JEE Pattern: Given alcohol, find Grignard + carbonyl combination (work backward!)
Reaction 4: Nucleophilic Addition - Addition of NH₃ Derivatives
General Pattern:
H₂N-G N-G
| ‖
R-C=O → R-C + H₂O
| |
H (or R') H (or R')
Table of Derivatives:
| Reagent (H₂N-G) | Product Name | Example Product |
|---|---|---|
| NH₃ | Imine (not stable) | R-CH=NH |
| NH₂OH (Hydroxylamine) | Oxime | R-CH=N-OH |
| NH₂-NH₂ (Hydrazine) | Hydrazone | R-CH=N-NH₂ |
| NH₂-NH-C₆H₅ (Phenylhydrazine) | Phenylhydrazone | R-CH=N-NH-C₆H₅ |
| NH₂-NH-CO-NH₂ (Semicarbazide) | Semicarbazone | R-CH=N-NH-CO-NH₂ |
Mechanism (for oxime formation):
Step 1: Nucleophilic attack
δ- OH
NH₂OH → C=O → C-NH₂OH
|
Step 2: Proton transfer + water elimination
C-NH₂OH → C=N-OH + H₂O
| |
(Oxime)
Importance:
- Identification/characterization of aldehydes/ketones (crystalline derivatives)
- 2,4-DNP test (2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine) → orange/red precipitate (qualitative test!)
Reagent: 2,4-Dinitrophenylhydrazine (2,4-DNP)
Reaction:
2,4-DNP
R-CHO ────────→ R-CH=N-NH-C₆H₃(NO₂)₂
(Orange/yellow/red precipitate)
Use: Distinguishes aldehydes/ketones from alcohols/ethers (positive test for C=O group!)
JEE Question Pattern: “Which compound will give positive 2,4-DNP test?”
- Aldehydes: ✓
- Ketones: ✓
- Alcohols: ✗
- Ethers: ✗
Reaction 5: Aldol Condensation (α-H Required!)
Condition: Aldehyde or ketone must have α-hydrogen (H on carbon next to C=O)
Reaction (Self-condensation):
dil. NaOH OH -H₂O
2 CH₃CHO ─────────→ CH₃-CH-CH₂-CHO ────────→ CH₃-CH=CH-CHO
(or dil. KOH) | (Crotonaldehyde,
CH₃ α,β-unsaturated aldehyde)
(Aldol, 3-hydroxybutanal)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Enolate formation (α-H removed by OH⁻)
H O O⁻
| ‖ OH⁻ ‖
CH₃-C-C-H ────────→ CH₂=C-H (Enolate ion, resonance stabilized)
|
H
Step 2: Nucleophilic attack on another aldehyde
O⁻ O
‖ ‖
CH₂=C-H + CH₃-CHO → CH₃-CH-CH₂-C-H
| |
O⁻ H
Step 3: Protonation
OH O
| ‖
CH₃-CH-CH₂-C-H (Aldol)
Step 4: Dehydration (heating)
OH O O
| ‖ Heat ‖
CH₃-CH-CH₂-CHO ───────→ CH₃-CH=CH-CHO + H₂O
Key Points:
- Aldol = Aldehyde + Alcohol (β-hydroxy aldehyde/ketone)
- Dehydration → α,β-unsaturated carbonyl (conjugated system)
- Requires α-H (no α-H → no aldol condensation!)
JEE Pattern:
- Formaldehyde (HCHO) has α-H? NO (no carbon next to C=O!) → no aldol
- Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO) has α-H? YES (CH₃ has H!) → aldol ✓
- Benzaldehyde (C₆H₅CHO) has α-H? NO (C₆H₅ is benzene, no α-H!) → no aldol
Memory Trick: “Aldol needs α-hydrogen - A for α!”
Reaction 6: Cannizzaro Reaction (No α-H!)
Condition: Aldehyde with NO α-hydrogen + concentrated NaOH
Reaction (Disproportionation):
conc. NaOH
2 HCHO ───────────→ CH₃OH + HCOONa
(Methanol) (Sodium formate)
2 C₆H₅CHO ────conc. NaOH────→ C₆H₅CH₂OH + C₆H₅COONa
(Benzyl alcohol) (Sodium benzoate)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Nucleophilic attack by OH⁻ on one aldehyde
OH⁻ O⁻
| |
→ C=O → HO-C-H
| |
H H
Step 2: Hydride transfer to another aldehyde
O⁻ O⁻
| |
HO-C-H + C=O → HO-C⁺ + HC-O⁻ → HCOO⁻ + H-C-OH
| | | |
H H H H
Net Result: One aldehyde oxidized to carboxylate, other reduced to alcohol!
Cannizzaro vs Aldol:
| Feature | Aldol | Cannizzaro |
|---|---|---|
| α-H? | YES (required) | NO (forbidden!) |
| Base strength | Dilute (NaOH/KOH) | Concentrated |
| Products | β-hydroxy carbonyl | Alcohol + carboxylate |
| Examples | CH₃CHO, CH₃COCH₃ | HCHO, C₆H₅CHO |
Memory Trick: “Cannizzaro Craves Concentrated base, aldol likes dilute!”
Reaction 7: Oxidation
Aldehydes (Easy to Oxidize):
| Reagent | Observation | Product |
|---|---|---|
| Fehling’s solution | Blue Cu²⁺ → Red Cu₂O ppt | R-COOH |
| Tollens’ reagent | Silver mirror forms | R-COO⁻ + Ag↓ |
| K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ | Orange → Green | R-COOH |
| KMnO₄ | Purple → Colorless/Brown | R-COOH |
Ketones:
- Do NOT get oxidized under normal conditions (no H on C=O carbon!)
- Very harsh conditions → C-C bond breaks (destructive)
Tollens’ Test (The Silver Mirror Test):
[Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺ + OH⁻
R-CHO ────────────────────→ R-COO⁻ + Ag↓ + H₂O
(Silver mirror on test tube wall!)
Observation: Shiny silver mirror on inside of test tube
Fehling’s Test:
Fehling's A + B
R-CHO ────────────────→ R-COO⁻ + Cu₂O↓ (Red precipitate)
(heat)
Observation: Blue solution → Red precipitate (Cu²⁺ → Cu₂O)
Question: How to distinguish between CH₃CHO (acetaldehyde) and CH₃COCH₃ (acetone)?
Answer:
| Test | Aldehyde (CH₃CHO) | Ketone (CH₃COCH₃) |
|---|---|---|
| Tollens’ reagent | Silver mirror ✓ | No reaction ✗ |
| Fehling’s solution | Red ppt (Cu₂O) ✓ | No reaction ✗ |
| 2,4-DNP | Orange ppt ✓ | Orange ppt ✓ |
Best Test: Tollens’ or Fehling’s (only aldehydes give positive!)
Reaction 8: Reduction
Reagents:
- LiAlH₄ (powerful reducer)
- NaBH₄ (milder reducer)
- H₂/Ni (catalytic hydrogenation)
Reaction:
LiAlH₄ or NaBH₄ OH
| |
R-C=O → R-C-H
| |
H (aldehyde) H (1° alcohol)
LiAlH₄ or NaBH₄ OH
| |
R-C=O → R-C-R'
| |
R' (ketone) R' (2° alcohol)
Examples:
LiAlH₄
CH₃CHO ──────→ CH₃CH₂OH (Ethanol, 1° alcohol)
LiAlH₄
CH₃COCH₃ ──────→ (CH₃)₂CHOH (Isopropanol, 2° alcohol)
Mechanism (simplified):
Step 1: Hydride (H⁻) attack from LiAlH₄
δ- O⁻
H⁻ → C=O → H-C-R
|
Step 2: Protonation
O⁻ OH
H-C-R + H₃O⁺ → H-C-R
| |
Reaction 9: Clemmensen Reduction (C=O → CH₂)
Reagent: Zn-Hg / HCl
Reaction:
Zn-Hg/HCl
R-CO-R' ────────→ R-CH₂-R' (Complete reduction to alkane!)
Example:
Zn-Hg/HCl
C₆H₅-CO-CH₃ ──────────→ C₆H₅-CH₂-CH₃
(Acetophenone) (Ethylbenzene)
Use: Convert carbonyl to methylene (CH₂) group
Alternative: Wolff-Kishner reduction (NH₂-NH₂, KOH, heat) - same result, basic conditions
Reaction 10: Haloform Reaction (Methyl Ketones Only!)
Condition: Methyl ketone (R-CO-CH₃) + I₂/NaOH or Cl₂/NaOH or Br₂/NaOH
Reaction:
I₂/NaOH
R-CO-CH₃ ──────────→ R-COO⁻Na⁺ + CHI₃↓
(Sodium carboxylate) (Iodoform, yellow ppt!)
Example:
I₂/NaOH
CH₃-CO-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃COO⁻Na⁺ + CHI₃↓
(Sodium acetate) (Iodoform, yellow ppt)
Mechanism:
Step 1: Halogenation of α-carbons (all 3 H replaced)
CH₃-CO-R + 3I₂ + 3OH⁻ → CI₃-CO-R + 3I⁻ + 3H₂O
Step 2: Nucleophilic attack by OH⁻ (cleavage)
O⁻OH
|
CI₃-C-R → R-COO⁻ + CI₃⁻
|
O
Step 3: Protonation of CI₃⁻
CI₃⁻ + H₂O → CHI₃↓ + OH⁻
(Yellow precipitate!)
Observation: Yellow precipitate of iodoform (CHI₃)
Works with:
- Methyl ketones: R-CO-CH₃ ✓
- Acetaldehyde: CH₃-CHO ✓ (only aldehyde that works!)
- Ethanol: CH₃-CH₂-OH ✓ (oxidizes to CH₃CHO first, then haloform)
JEE Pattern: Iodoform test distinguishes methyl ketones from other ketones!
Positive Iodoform Test (Yellow ppt with I₂/NaOH):
Structure must have:
O OH
‖ |
R-C-CH₃ OR CH₃-C-H OR CH₃-C-H
|
R
(Methyl ketone) (Acetaldehyde) (2° alcohol with CH₃-CHOH-)
Examples:
- CH₃COCH₃ (acetone) → ✓
- CH₃CH₂COCH₃ (MEK) → ✓
- C₆H₅COCH₃ (acetophenone) → ✓
- CH₃CHO (acetaldehyde) → ✓
- CH₃CH(OH)CH₃ (isopropanol) → ✓ (oxidizes to acetone first)
- CH₃CH₂CHO (propionaldehyde) → ✗ (no CH₃-CO- group)
Special Reactions: Cross-Aldol and Mixed Cannizzaro
Cross-Aldol Condensation
Problem: Mixing two different aldehydes/ketones gives mixture of 4 products!
Solution: Use one component without α-H (can’t form enolate, only acts as electrophile)
Example:
dil. NaOH
C₆H₅CHO + CH₃CHO ──────────→ C₆H₅-CH=CH-CHO
(No α-H) (Has α-H) (Cinnamaldehyde)
Strategy:
- Aromatic aldehyde (no α-H) → electrophile only
- Aliphatic aldehyde (has α-H) → forms enolate, attacks aromatic aldehyde
Cross-Cannizzaro Reaction
Reaction:
conc. NaOH
HCHO + C₆H₅CHO ───────────→ CH₃OH + C₆H₅COO⁻Na⁺
Pattern: HCHO is better hydride donor → gets oxidized preferentially
Result: HCHO → CH₃OH (reduced), C₆H₅CHO → C₆H₅COO⁻ (oxidized)
Memory Tricks & Patterns
The Master Mnemonic: “CARBONYL REACTIONS DOMINATE CHEMISTRY”
Cyanohydrin (HCN addition)
Aldol (needs α-H, dilute base)
Reduction (LiAlH₄ → alcohol)
Bisulfite (NaHSO₃ addition, white ppt)
Oxidation (aldehydes only! Tollens, Fehling)
NH₃ derivatives (oxime, hydrazone, semicarbazone)
Yellow ppt (Iodoform test for methyl ketones)
LiAlH₄ (powerful reducer, reduces everything)
Rosenmund (acyl chloride → aldehyde)
Electrophilic C (δ+ carbon in C=O)
Aldehydes more reactive than ketones
Clemmensen (C=O → CH₂, Zn-Hg/HCl)
Tollens’ test (silver mirror for aldehydes)
Iodoform (methyl ketones, yellow ppt)
Ozonolysis (alkene → aldehydes/ketones)
Nucleophilic addition (characteristic reaction)
Semicarbazone (crystalline derivative)
DNPH test (2,4-DNP, orange ppt for C=O)
Oxime (NH₂OH addition product)
Methyl ketones (Iodoform positive)
Increase in carbon (Grignard addition)
No α-H → Cannizzaro (conc. NaOH)
Aldehyde has terminal C=O
Tautomerization (enol ⇌ keto)
Electrophilic aromatic substitution (deactivating C=O)
Cannizzaro (no α-H, conc. NaOH, disproportionation)
HCN (cyanohydrin, useful intermediate)
Enolate (α-H removal in aldol)
Mechanism (nucleophilic addition, not substitution!)
Isotopes (α, β positions relative to C=O)
Steric hindrance (aldehydes < ketones)
Terminal C=O (aldehyde), internal C=O (ketone)
Reactivity (aldehyde > ketone)
Yield (PCC stops at aldehyde, K₂Cr₂O₇ goes to acid)
Quick Reaction Summary
Nucleophilic Addition:
- HCN → Cyanohydrin
- NaHSO₃ → Bisulfite adduct (white ppt)
- RMgX → Alcohol (after H₃O⁺)
- NH₂OH → Oxime
- NH₂-NH₂ → Hydrazone
- NH₂-NH-C₆H₅ → Phenylhydrazone
Condensation Reactions:
- Aldol: α-H + dilute base → β-hydroxy carbonyl → α,β-unsaturated
- Cannizzaro: No α-H + conc. base → alcohol + carboxylate
Oxidation/Reduction:
- Oxidation: Aldehyde → Carboxylic acid (Tollens, Fehling, K₂Cr₂O₇)
- Reduction: Aldehyde/Ketone → Alcohol (LiAlH₄, NaBH₄)
- Clemmensen: C=O → CH₂ (Zn-Hg/HCl)
Special Tests:
- Tollens’: Aldehyde → Silver mirror
- Fehling’s: Aldehyde → Red Cu₂O ppt
- 2,4-DNP: Aldehyde/Ketone → Orange ppt
- Iodoform: Methyl ketone → Yellow CHI₃ ppt
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Wrong: Using aldol condensation for aldehydes without α-H Right:
- Aldol: Requires α-H, dilute base (NaOH/KOH)
- Cannizzaro: No α-H, concentrated base
Examples:
- CH₃CHO (has α-H) → Aldol ✓, Cannizzaro ✗
- HCHO (no α-H) → Aldol ✗, Cannizzaro ✓
- C₆H₅CHO (no α-H) → Aldol ✗, Cannizzaro ✓
JEE Impact: This distinction is tested every year!
Wrong: Using K₂Cr₂O₇ to prepare aldehyde from 1° alcohol Right:
- PCC (in CH₂Cl₂): Stops at aldehyde stage
- K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺: Goes all the way to carboxylic acid
Remember:
1° Alcohol + PCC → Aldehyde (stops!)
1° Alcohol + K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ → Carboxylic acid (continues!)
Wrong: Thinking all aldehydes give iodoform test Right: Only acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO) among aldehydes!
Iodoform positive:
- All methyl ketones (R-CO-CH₃)
- Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO) - exception!
- Secondary alcohols with CH₃-CH(OH)- group (oxidize to methyl ketone first)
Memory: Structure must have CH₃-CO- or CH₃-CHO group!
Wrong: Thinking ketones are more reactive than aldehydes Right: Aldehydes » Ketones (in nucleophilic addition)
Reasons:
- Steric: Aldehydes less hindered (1 R group vs 2 in ketones)
- Electronic: Aldehydes less electron-rich (1 +I group vs 2 in ketones)
Consequence: Aldehydes react faster with nucleophiles!
Wrong: Expecting ketones to give positive Tollens’/Fehling’s test Right: Only aldehydes reduce Tollens’/Fehling’s!
Why? Aldehydes easily oxidized to carboxylic acids, ketones resist oxidation (no H on C=O carbon)
Exception: α-Hydroxy ketones (like CH₃-CO-CH(OH)-CH₃) may give positive under certain conditions, but standard ketones don’t!
Practice Problems
Level 1: Foundation (NCERT Style)
Question: Why is the carbonyl carbon in aldehydes/ketones electrophilic?
Solution:
The carbonyl carbon is electrophilic (electron-deficient) due to:
Electronegativity difference:
- Oxygen (EN = 3.5) is more electronegative than carbon (EN = 2.5)
- Oxygen pulls electron density from C=O bond toward itself
Polarization:
δ+ δ-
C=O
- Carbon becomes electron-deficient (δ+)
- Oxygen becomes electron-rich (δ-)
- Result:
- Electrophilic carbon attracts nucleophiles
- Nucleophilic addition is the characteristic reaction!
In short: Oxygen hogs electrons → carbon becomes electron-poor → nucleophiles attack carbon!
Question: How will you distinguish between: (a) Propanal and propanone (b) Acetaldehyde and acetone
Solution:
Both pairs are aldehyde vs ketone - same tests work!
Test 1: Tollens’ Reagent
- Aldehyde (Propanal/Acetaldehyde): Silver mirror forms ✓
- Ketone (Propanone/Acetone): No reaction ✗
Test 2: Fehling’s Solution
- Aldehyde: Blue solution → Red Cu₂O precipitate ✓
- Ketone: No reaction (stays blue) ✗
Test 3: Iodoform Test (specific for part b)
- Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO): Yellow CHI₃ precipitate ✓
- Acetone (CH₃COCH₃): Yellow CHI₃ precipitate ✓
For (a): Use Tollens’ or Fehling’s (aldehydes positive, ketones negative) For (b): Both give iodoform! Use Tollens’/Fehling’s instead.
Question: Complete the reactions:
(a) CH₃CHO + HCN → ?
(b) CH₃COCH₃ + NaHSO₃ → ?
Solution:
(a) CH₃CHO + HCN → Cyanohydrin
HCN OH
CH₃CHO → CH₃-CH-CN
(2-Hydroxypropanenitrile, acetaldehyde cyanohydrin)
(b) CH₃COCH₃ + NaHSO₃ → Bisulfite adduct
NaHSO₃ OH
CH₃COCH₃ ────────→ (CH₃)₂C-SO₃Na
(White crystalline solid)
Note: Both are nucleophilic addition reactions!
Level 2: JEE Main Style
Question: Which of the following will NOT give a positive iodoform test?
(A) Acetone (CH₃COCH₃) (B) Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO) (C) Isopropyl alcohol ((CH₃)₂CHOH) (D) Propionaldehyde (CH₃CH₂CHO)
Solution: (D) Propionaldehyde
Analysis: Iodoform test is positive for compounds with CH₃-CO- or CH₃-CHO group (or alcohols that oxidize to these).
(A) Acetone (CH₃-CO-CH₃):
- Has CH₃-CO- group → Positive ✓
(B) Acetaldehyde (CH₃-CHO):
- Has CH₃-CHO group (only aldehyde that works!) → Positive ✓
(C) Isopropyl alcohol ((CH₃)₂CH-OH):
- Oxidizes to CH₃-CO-CH₃ (acetone) → Positive ✓
(D) Propionaldehyde (CH₃-CH₂-CHO):
- Has CH₃-CH₂-CHO, NOT CH₃-CHO or CH₃-CO-
- No methyl group directly attached to C=O → Negative ✗
Answer: (D)
Question: Arrange the following in increasing order of reactivity toward nucleophilic addition: I. Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO) II. Acetone (CH₃COCH₃) III. Benzaldehyde (C₆H₅CHO) IV. Formaldehyde (HCHO)
(A) II < III < I < IV (B) IV < I < III < II (C) III < II < I < IV (D) II < I < III < IV
Solution: (A) II < III < I < IV
Analysis:
Factors affecting reactivity:
- Steric hindrance: More alkyl groups → less reactive
- Electronic (+I effect): More alkyl groups → less electrophilic C=O
IV. Formaldehyde (HCHO):
- No alkyl groups, only H
- Most reactive (least hindered, most electrophilic)
I. Acetaldehyde (CH₃CHO):
- 1 alkyl group (CH₃)
- More reactive than ketones
III. Benzaldehyde (C₆H₅CHO):
- C₆H₅ group (aromatic, -M effect reduces C=O electrophilicity)
- But still aldehyde (more reactive than ketones)
II. Acetone (CH₃COCH₃):
- 2 alkyl groups (most hindered)
- Least reactive
Increasing order: II < III < I < IV
Answer: (A)
Memory: HCHO (no alkyl) > R-CHO (1 alkyl) > Ar-CHO > R-CO-R’ (2 alkyl)
Question: Acetaldehyde reacts with dilute NaOH to give compound (A). On heating, (A) gives (B). Identify (A) and (B).
Solution:
Reaction: Aldol Condensation
Step 1: Aldol formation (dilute NaOH)
dil. NaOH OH O
2 CH₃CHO ─────────→ CH₃-CH-CH₂-C-H
| |
CH₃ H
(3-Hydroxybutanal, "Aldol")
Compound A = 3-Hydroxybutanal (CH₃-CH(OH)-CH₂-CHO)
Step 2: Dehydration (heating)
Heat O
A ─────────→ CH₃-CH=CH-C-H + H₂O
(Crotonaldehyde, but-2-enal)
Compound B = But-2-enal (Crotonaldehyde, α,β-unsaturated aldehyde)
Key Points:
- Acetaldehyde has α-H (on CH₃) → can undergo aldol
- Heating causes dehydration (β-OH elimination) → conjugated system
Level 3: JEE Advanced Style
Question: An organic compound (A) with molecular formula C₃H₆O gives a positive 2,4-DNP test but negative Tollens’ test. (A) reacts with I₂/NaOH to give yellow precipitate and sodium salt (B). Identify (A) and (B) with reactions.
Solution:
Analysis:
- Positive 2,4-DNP test → (A) has carbonyl group (aldehyde or ketone)
- Negative Tollens’ test → (A) is NOT an aldehyde → must be ketone
- Molecular formula C₃H₆O with ketone → CH₃-CO-CH₃ (acetone, propanone)
- Positive iodoform test → confirms methyl ketone (CH₃-CO-)
Compound A = Acetone (CH₃-CO-CH₃, Propanone)
Reactions:
(1) 2,4-DNP Test:
2,4-DNP
CH₃-CO-CH₃ ────────→ (CH₃)₂C=N-NH-C₆H₃(NO₂)₂
(Orange/yellow precipitate)
(2) Tollens’ Test:
CH₃-CO-CH₃ + Tollens' reagent → No reaction (ketone doesn't oxidize!)
(3) Iodoform Reaction:
I₂/NaOH
CH₃-CO-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃COO⁻Na⁺ + CHI₃↓
(B, Sodium acetate) (Yellow ppt)
Compound B = Sodium acetate (CH₃COO⁻Na⁺)
Verification:
- C₃H₆O = CH₃-CO-CH₃ ✓
- 2,4-DNP positive (C=O present) ✓
- Tollens’ negative (ketone) ✓
- Iodoform positive (CH₃-CO- group) ✓
Question: Compound (X) with molecular formula C₄H₈O does not react with Fehling’s solution but gives positive iodoform test. (X) reacts with LiAlH₄ to give (Y). Identify (X) and (Y).
Solution:
Analysis:
- No reaction with Fehling’s → (X) is NOT an aldehyde → ketone
- Positive iodoform test → (X) is a methyl ketone (R-CO-CH₃)
- Molecular formula C₄H₈O with methyl ketone → CH₃-CO-CH₂-CH₃
- LiAlH₄ reduction → ketone → 2° alcohol
Compound X = Butanone (Methyl ethyl ketone, MEK, CH₃-CO-CH₂-CH₃)
Reactions:
(1) Fehling’s Test:
CH₃-CO-CH₂-CH₃ + Fehling's solution → No reaction (ketone!)
(2) Iodoform Test:
I₂/NaOH
CH₃-CO-CH₂-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃CH₂COO⁻Na⁺ + CHI₃↓
(Sodium propanoate) (Yellow ppt)
(3) Reduction:
LiAlH₄ OH
CH₃-CO-CH₂-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃-CH-CH₂-CH₃
(Butan-2-ol, Y)
Compound Y = Butan-2-ol (CH₃-CH(OH)-CH₂-CH₃, 2° alcohol)
Verification:
- C₄H₈O = CH₃-CO-C₂H₅ ✓
- Fehling’s negative (ketone) ✓
- Iodoform positive (CH₃-CO- group) ✓
- Reduction gives 2° alcohol ✓
Question: How would you carry out the following conversions? (a) Benzene → Acetophenone (b) Ethanol → Acetaldehyde (c) Propene → Propanone
Solution:
(a) Benzene → Acetophenone (C₆H₅-CO-CH₃)
Route: Friedel-Crafts Acylation
CH₃COCl/AlCl₃
C₆H₆ ─────────────────→ C₆H₅-CO-CH₃
(Acetophenone)
Single-step synthesis! Friedel-Crafts acylation directly introduces -CO-CH₃ group.
(b) Ethanol → Acetaldehyde
Route: Controlled Oxidation
PCC/CH₂Cl₂ O
or CuO/573 K ‖
CH₃CH₂-OH ─────────────→ CH₃-C-H
(Acetaldehyde)
Key: Use PCC (mild oxidant) to stop at aldehyde stage!
- If K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ used → goes to CH₃COOH (acetic acid)
(c) Propene → Propanone (Acetone)
Route: Hydration of Alkyne
Step 1: Convert propene to propyne (difficult! Better route below)
Better Route: Markovnikov addition + oxidation
Step 1: Hydration (Markovnikov)
H₂SO₄/H₂O
CH₃-CH=CH₂ ────────────→ CH₃-CH(OH)-CH₃
(Isopropanol, 2° alcohol)
Step 2: Oxidation
K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ O
CH₃-CH(OH)-CH₃ ──────────→ CH₃-C-CH₃
(Propanone/Acetone)
Alternative Route (via Wacker Process - industrial):
PdCl₂/CuCl₂ O
O₂, H₂O ‖
CH₃-CH=CH₂ ─────────────→ CH₃-C-CH₃
(Direct oxidation to ketone!)
For JEE, the hydration + oxidation route is more common!
Question: An aldehyde (A) does not undergo aldol condensation but gives Cannizzaro reaction. (A) reacts with another aldehyde (B) in the presence of dilute NaOH to give cinnamaldehyde (C₆H₅-CH=CH-CHO). Identify (A) and (B).
Solution:
Analysis:
Aldehyde (A):
- No aldol condensation → (A) has no α-hydrogen
- Gives Cannizzaro → confirms no α-H, conc. base
- Forms cinnamaldehyde with (B) + dilute NaOH → cross-aldol (acts as electrophile only)
Possible (A) without α-H: HCHO, C₆H₅CHO, (CH₃)₃C-CHO, etc.
Aldehyde (B):
- Gives cross-aldol with (A) → (B) must have α-hydrogen (forms enolate)
- Product is C₆H₅-CH=CH-CHO (cinnamaldehyde)
Working backward from product:
C₆H₅-CH=CH-CHO (Cinnamaldehyde)
This is dehydration product of:
OH
|
C₆H₅-CH-CH₂-CHO (aldol adduct)
Aldol adduct forms from:
C₆H₅-CHO + CH₃-CHO ──dil. NaOH──→ C₆H₅-CH(OH)-CH₂-CHO
(No α-H) (Has α-H)
(A) (B)
Then dehydration:
C₆H₅-CH(OH)-CH₂-CHO ──Heat──→ C₆H₅-CH=CH-CHO + H₂O
Answer:
- A = Benzaldehyde (C₆H₅-CHO) (no α-H, acts as electrophile)
- B = Acetaldehyde (CH₃-CHO) (has α-H, forms enolate)
Verification:
- Benzaldehyde: No α-H ✓, Cannizzaro ✓
- Acetaldehyde: Has α-H ✓
- Cross-aldol product: Cinnamaldehyde ✓
Quick Revision Box
| Situation | Formula/Approach | Key Point |
|---|---|---|
| Aldehyde vs Ketone (oxidation) | Tollens’ or Fehling’s test | Aldehyde positive, ketone negative |
| Methyl ketone identification | Iodoform test (I₂/NaOH) | Yellow CHI₃ ppt |
| Carbonyl identification | 2,4-DNP test | Orange ppt for aldehydes AND ketones |
| 1° alcohol → aldehyde | PCC/CH₂Cl₂ | Stops at aldehyde (K₂Cr₂O₇ goes to acid!) |
| 2° alcohol → ketone | K₂Cr₂O₇/H⁺ or PCC | Any oxidant works |
| Aldehyde + Grignard | RCHO + R’MgX → 2° alcohol | After H₃O⁺ workup |
| Ketone + Grignard | RCOR’ + R"MgX → 3° alcohol | After H₃O⁺ workup |
| Has α-H + dilute base | Aldol condensation | β-hydroxy carbonyl → α,β-unsaturated |
| No α-H + conc. base | Cannizzaro reaction | Disproportionation: alcohol + carboxylate |
| Reactivity order | HCHO > R-CHO > Ar-CHO > R-CO-R' | Steric + electronic effects |
| Complete reduction C=O → CH₂ | Clemmensen (Zn-Hg/HCl) or Wolff-Kishner | Removes oxygen completely |
| Cyanohydrin formation | HCN addition | Useful for chain extension |
Connection to Other Topics
Prerequisites (Review these first):
- Alcohols - oxidation to aldehydes/ketones, Grignard products
- Organic Principles: Nucleophilic Addition - mechanism understanding
- Hydrocarbons: Alkenes - ozonolysis to aldehydes/ketones
Related Topics:
- Carboxylic Acids - oxidation product of aldehydes
- Phenols - Reimer-Tiemann gives aldehydes
- Ethers - comparison of C-O functional groups
- Nitrogen Compounds: Amines - derivatives (imines, enamines)
Advanced Applications:
- Aldol condensation in synthesis (carbon-carbon bond formation)
- Grignard reactions (alcohols of any degree)
- Protecting groups (acetals/ketals)
- Natural products containing carbonyl groups
Teacher’s Summary
1. Carbonyl Group = Electrophilic Carbon:
- C=O polarized (C δ+, O δ-) → nucleophilic addition reactions
- Aldehydes > Ketones (reactivity) due to steric + electronic factors
2. Preparation Methods:
- 1° alcohol + PCC → aldehyde (stops here!)
- 1° alcohol + K₂Cr₂O₇ → carboxylic acid (goes further)
- 2° alcohol + oxidant → ketone (stops)
- Ozonolysis → aldehydes/ketones (breaks C=C)
3. Nucleophilic Addition Arsenal:
- HCN → Cyanohydrin (useful intermediate)
- NaHSO₃ → Bisulfite adduct (purification)
- RMgX → Alcohols (1°, 2°, or 3° depending on carbonyl)
- NH₂-G → Derivatives (oxime, hydrazone, semicarbazone for identification)
4. Condensation Reactions (α-H dependent):
- Aldol: α-H + dilute base → β-hydroxy carbonyl → α,β-unsaturated
- Cannizzaro: No α-H + conc. base → disproportionation (alcohol + carboxylate)
5. Oxidation/Reduction:
- Aldehydes oxidize easily (Tollens’ → Ag mirror, Fehling’s → Cu₂O red ppt)
- Ketones resist oxidation (no reaction with Tollens’/Fehling’s)
- Both reduce to alcohols (LiAlH₄, NaBH₄, H₂/Ni)
- Clemmensen/Wolff-Kishner: Complete reduction (C=O → CH₂)
6. JEE-Specific Tests:
- 2,4-DNP: Aldehyde + Ketone (orange ppt)
- Tollens’/Fehling’s: Aldehyde only (silver mirror/red ppt)
- Iodoform: Methyl ketones + acetaldehyde (yellow CHI₃ ppt)
7. JEE Strategy:
- Master qualitative tests (distinguish aldehydes vs ketones)
- Know reactivity order (HCHO > R-CHO > Ar-CHO > R-CO-R')
- Practice aldol vs Cannizzaro decision (α-H presence!)
- Remember PCC stops at aldehyde, K₂Cr₂O₇ goes to acid
- Understand Grignard pattern (formaldehyde → 1°, aldehyde → 2°, ketone → 3°)
“Aldehydes and ketones are the workhorses of organic chemistry - oxidize, reduce, add nucleophiles, condense with themselves - they do it all! Master the carbonyl group, and you’ve unlocked 30% of organic chemistry reactions. For JEE, focus on qualitative tests, α-H dependent reactions, and Grignard patterns!”
Previous Topic: ← Ethers - The unreactive oxygen bridge Next Topic: Carboxylic Acids → - The acidic oxidation products!